How closely have you looked at other cars like the Fit or Versa? - Page 2 - Toyota Yaris Forums

The Stig · 05-18-2007, 06:53 PM

As a daily driver, I want:

1, cheap (good MPG, upkeep)
2, reliable
3, at least moderately fun to drive
4, good resale value

Didn't pick Honda Fit because dealers want $4000 markup, even he told me to "ignore" that little sticker...Greedy mofos not going to earn a penny from me. Besides, I really don't like the latest Honda/Acura manual gearbox and clutch. So fun to drive is definitely out the window....

Didn't pick Versa because it's a bit boring looking for my taste...I didn't even bother to test drive one....However, it does seem like more of a "proper" car.

Picked the Yaris. Mainly because friend of mine hooked me up (12.8k out the door)...Love the clutch (compare to Hondas/Acuras), cheap, reliable, wheels all the way out in the corners (tiny overhangs = nimble)....Also, as I recently found out a feature that Toyota never advertised for the Yaris...It actually IS a chic magnet!! You have no idea how many girls telling me how cute this car is...

craigq · 05-18-2007, 10:15 PM

We didn't consider the Nissan Versa. We had a 2003 Nissan Sentra with the QG18DE 1.8L L4 that leaked coolant (probably from day one). Had the head gasket replaced under warranty, it started leaking coolant again shortly thereafter. There are plenty of used oil analysis onhttp://www.bobistheoilguy.com that show the engine has problems. Based on that experience no more Nissan for me (at least for now). The optional QR25 didn't fare much better (piston ring problems, head gaskets etc). I think that the engine in the Versa is fairly new and I don't feel like being a guinea pig, regardless if it's under warranty or not.

We test drove the Fit, handling was stiffer than the Yaris, but the ride was also rougher. A wide-open fuel filler door seemed a little old-fashioned. The doors felt cheap, as did the door handles. Interior space, like most others have said, is amazing. I did not like how the automatic transmission shifted, very clunky/jerky at times. Maybe it was just the test drive car? I also was unable to find any information on either the engine or transmission.

We decided on the Yaris Sedan. The 1NZFE engine has been around forever, I've not read too many bad things about it (crankshaft position sensor failure on the earlier engines, at least there's no trend of head gasket failures). Also no real bad trends for the transmission (I'm assuming the U340 transaxle is the same one used in the Echo).

Blenjar · 05-18-2007, 10:33 PM

MY SISTER BOUGHT THE VERSA SEDAN automatic with the keyless entry crap.

Here are the up(s):
Engine is extremely quiet and IMO smooth transition in automatic.
trunk is huge
Here are the downssszzzz:
Car is ugly
Not worth its price in te high 16,000 (even a mazda 3 looks better)
the rims are fugly for its price
car is ugly again
UGLY
I just think its worthless having a keyless entry if it has no remote start..
the car is ugly

Those are reviews..i've driven it many times...engine is nice n quiet..thats bout it.

-- Blen

Blenjar · 05-18-2007, 10:35 PM

The fit IMO like many other FIT haters or professional reviewers...it looks like a mini van.
I don't dig vans...im a man. sedan or 2 door.

-- Blen

kurokoma-kun · 05-18-2007, 10:48 PM

Like many here I also compared Fit and Versa, and chose Yaris primarily for price and styling.

I did see my first Versa on the road today--actually being pulled OFF the road by police officer who flew out of his hiding place right in front of me to bag him. It is a quick little thing...I am soooo glad I did not give chase. But I agree with those who say it looks fugly from every angle.

OtownYaris · 05-19-2007, 10:52 AM

I test drove the Yaris and the Fit and I liked the Fit more in every way except looks. But at $3000+ more in price and lower MPG I had to go with the Yaris. Also, Hondas are always getting stolen here in Orlando. If the cost of living wasn't so high here, I would have bought the Fit.

Pavel Olavich · 05-19-2007, 01:08 PM

I checked out the Fit and Yaris only....why waste time looking at any and all Korean jobs? Low quality, low MPG, bigger engines with LESS power, lower resale value, see what I mean? Why waste time even considering the Nissan Versa (Renault)?

So it came down to H & T.

For me it was about MPG, and Cost. That simple. I don't give a rat's a$$ about a car's looks, power, room, because all I wanted was a get to work car. I have nothing against the Fit and think the world of it but it lost out to the Yaris in regards to purchase price and MPG.

So for $13,100 + shipping and sales tax, I got the 2007 Yaris LB, and I'm happy. So is my retirement $ plans....leave the multi-thousand $$ mods, and extras to those that will have nothing come age 60...hehehe..I'd rather invest in condo rentals then cars...

Typer73 · 05-19-2007, 11:14 PM

I wasn't even looking for a new car... saw the Yaris on a tv commercial, fell in love with the liftback... checked it out on the toyota.com website... fell even more in love with the price... aggravated everyone around me constantly talking about the Yaris until the hubby told me to just go buy it.

The only reason I even did a test drive was the salesman almost insisted on it, and I drove the sedan because they didn't have a liftback in stock. Ordered it that day, took 3 weeks to come in.

Fit & Versa have too many doors (5) and are fugly; and whichever other one that has 3 doors (Kia? Hyundai?) not a brand I would buy--heard too many bad things about them.

vwtech · 09-05-2010, 06:47 PM

I didnt drive the fit and I and kinda kicking myself in the but because when I drove one the other day I reall liked it. the interior is alot nice and the seats are way better the yaris does have that go kart feel to it which is nice. I would never even consider the versa just plain ugly and doesnt have any sort of sport feel to it.

yariphilia · 09-06-2010, 03:49 PM

lol, i actually kinda like my versa, but for me its getting 30mpg versus 42mpg in my yaris that keeps me driving it... that and my yaris is manual. the versa rides like a larger car, much smoother than my yaris was stock. as for the fit, i like them a lot. actually tried trading in my versa for one.

Gr8ful_Ken · 09-08-2010, 09:29 PM

When I first started researching to purchase a new car, i read several places about inconsistent build quality in the Versa, and then noticed that my local area was flooded with used Versas with 15k or less on them, not a good sign.

I drove the Yaris, the Fit, and the Kia Soul (I liked the looks of it, but was really looking for better mileage than that, and the clutch felt like a sponge).

I liked the exterior of the Yaris, and interior of The Fit. The fit was probably more fun to drive, but that exterior is absolutely awful.

So it came down to price... Yaris was cheaper. Then, 0% financing made it a no-brainer.

05-18-2007, 10:33 PM	#3
Blenjar View User's Garage Drives: Black Yaris 07 HB Join Date: Apr 2006 Location: CT Posts: 1,548	MY SISTER BOUGHT THE VERSA SEDAN automatic with the keyless entry crap. Here are the up(s): Engine is extremely quiet and IMO smooth transition in automatic. trunk is huge Here are the downssszzzz: Car is ugly Not worth its price in te high 16,000 (even a mazda 3 looks better) the rims are fugly for its price car is ugly again UGLY I just think its worthless having a keyless entry if it has no remote start.. the car is ugly Those are reviews..i've driven it many times...engine is nice n quiet..thats bout it. -- Blen __________________ http://www.360voice.com/tag/noobblenjar My Car http://www.yarisworld.com/forums/showthread.php?t=4245 My DJ www.PainlessWolf.com

05-18-2007, 10:35 PM	#4
Blenjar View User's Garage Drives: Black Yaris 07 HB Join Date: Apr 2006 Location: CT Posts: 1,548	The fit IMO like many other FIT haters or professional reviewers...it looks like a mini van. I don't dig vans...im a man. sedan or 2 door. -- Blen __________________ http://www.360voice.com/tag/noobblenjar My Car http://www.yarisworld.com/forums/showthread.php?t=4245 My DJ www.PainlessWolf.com

09-08-2010, 09:29 PM	#11
Gr8ful_Ken Drives: 2010 Yaris 5 door Join Date: Jul 2010 Location: Havre de Grace, MD Posts: 25	When I first started researching to purchase a new car, i read several places about inconsistent build quality in the Versa, and then noticed that my local area was flooded with used Versas with 15k or less on them, not a good sign. I drove the Yaris, the Fit, and the Kia Soul (I liked the looks of it, but was really looking for better mileage than that, and the clutch felt like a sponge). I liked the exterior of the Yaris, and interior of The Fit. The fit was probably more fun to drive, but that exterior is absolutely awful. So it came down to price... Yaris was cheaper. Then, 0% financing made it a no-brainer. __________________

Similar Threads
Thread	Thread Starter	Forum	Replies	Last Post
Consumer Reports not too pleased with Yaris	Befuddled	General Yaris / Vitz Discussion	132	02-28-2011 03:57 PM
I test drove a Yaris, Versa and FIT	CanadaCraig	New YARIS Purchase Forum	41	11-29-2008 10:18 PM
Test drove Fit, Versa and Yaris... Bought a Yaris!	AlexK	General Yaris / Vitz Discussion	49	09-10-2007 06:35 PM
What other cars you looked at ?	Bidoup	General Yaris / Vitz Discussion	42	09-14-2006 11:16 PM
How will this car do against other subcompacts (Fit, Versa)	Mess11	General Yaris / Vitz Discussion	23	02-02-2006 12:27 PM

05-18-2007, 06:53 PM	#1
The Stig View User's Garage Drives: 07 LB MM 5spd, 99 M Coupe Join Date: Apr 2007 Location: Nor Cal Posts: 34	As a daily driver, I want: 1, cheap (good MPG, upkeep) 2, reliable 3, at least moderately fun to drive 4, good resale value Didn't pick Honda Fit because dealers want $4000 markup, even he told me to "ignore" that little sticker...Greedy mofos not going to earn a penny from me. Besides, I really don't like the latest Honda/Acura manual gearbox and clutch. So fun to drive is definitely out the window.... Didn't pick Versa because it's a bit boring looking for my taste...I didn't even bother to test drive one....However, it does seem like more of a "proper" car. Picked the Yaris. Mainly because friend of mine hooked me up (12.8k out the door)...Love the clutch (compare to Hondas/Acuras), cheap, reliable, wheels all the way out in the corners (tiny overhangs = nimble)....Also, as I recently found out a feature that Toyota never advertised for the Yaris...It actually IS a chic magnet!! You have no idea how many girls telling me how cute this car is...

05-18-2007, 10:15 PM	#2
craigq Drives: '07 Yaris, '12 GLI Join Date: May 2007 Location: Ottawa Posts: 100	We didn't consider the Nissan Versa. We had a 2003 Nissan Sentra with the QG18DE 1.8L L4 that leaked coolant (probably from day one). Had the head gasket replaced under warranty, it started leaking coolant again shortly thereafter. There are plenty of used oil analysis onhttp://www.bobistheoilguy.com that show the engine has problems. Based on that experience no more Nissan for me (at least for now). The optional QR25 didn't fare much better (piston ring problems, head gaskets etc). I think that the engine in the Versa is fairly new and I don't feel like being a guinea pig, regardless if it's under warranty or not. We test drove the Fit, handling was stiffer than the Yaris, but the ride was also rougher. A wide-open fuel filler door seemed a little old-fashioned. The doors felt cheap, as did the door handles. Interior space, like most others have said, is amazing. I did not like how the automatic transmission shifted, very clunky/jerky at times. Maybe it was just the test drive car? I also was unable to find any information on either the engine or transmission. We decided on the Yaris Sedan. The 1NZFE engine has been around forever, I've not read too many bad things about it (crankshaft position sensor failure on the earlier engines, at least there's no trend of head gasket failures). Also no real bad trends for the transmission (I'm assuming the U340 transaxle is the same one used in the Echo).

05-18-2007, 10:48 PM	#5
kurokoma-kun Drives: 2007 Yaris HB Join Date: Apr 2007 Location: my own little world Posts: 1,256	Like many here I also compared Fit and Versa, and chose Yaris primarily for price and styling. I did see my first Versa on the road today--actually being pulled OFF the road by police officer who flew out of his hiding place right in front of me to bag him. It is a quick little thing...I am soooo glad I did not give chase. But I agree with those who say it looks fugly from every angle.

05-19-2007, 10:52 AM	#6
OtownYaris View User's Garage Drives: Meteorite Yaris Liftback Join Date: May 2007 Location: Apopka, FL Posts: 48	I test drove the Yaris and the Fit and I liked the Fit more in every way except looks. But at $3000+ more in price and lower MPG I had to go with the Yaris. Also, Hondas are always getting stolen here in Orlando. If the cost of living wasn't so high here, I would have bought the Fit.

05-19-2007, 01:08 PM	#7
Pavel Olavich Banned Drives: 2007 Yaris LB Join Date: Mar 2007 Location: Orange County, Calif Posts: 284	I checked out the Fit and Yaris only....why waste time looking at any and all Korean jobs? Low quality, low MPG, bigger engines with LESS power, lower resale value, see what I mean? Why waste time even considering the Nissan Versa (Renault)? So it came down to H & T. For me it was about MPG, and Cost. That simple. I don't give a rat's a$$ about a car's looks, power, room, because all I wanted was a get to work car. I have nothing against the Fit and think the world of it but it lost out to the Yaris in regards to purchase price and MPG. So for $13,100 + shipping and sales tax, I got the 2007 Yaris LB, and I'm happy. So is my retirement $ plans....leave the multi-thousand $$ mods, and extras to those that will have nothing come age 60...hehehe..I'd rather invest in condo rentals then cars...

05-19-2007, 11:14 PM	#8
Typer73 Tired of the Stars! View User's Garage Drives: '07 Meteorite LB Join Date: Dec 2006 Location: NE GA Posts: 281	I wasn't even looking for a new car... saw the Yaris on a tv commercial, fell in love with the liftback... checked it out on the toyota.com website... fell even more in love with the price... aggravated everyone around me constantly talking about the Yaris until the hubby told me to just go buy it. The only reason I even did a test drive was the salesman almost insisted on it, and I drove the sedan because they didn't have a liftback in stock. Ordered it that day, took 3 weeks to come in. Fit & Versa have too many doors (5) and are fugly; and whichever other one that has 3 doors (Kia? Hyundai?) not a brand I would buy--heard too many bad things about them.

09-05-2010, 06:47 PM	#9
vwtech Banned Drives: 09 jetta tdi dsg Join Date: May 2010 Location: mary esther fl Posts: 91	I didnt drive the fit and I and kinda kicking myself in the but because when I drove one the other day I reall liked it. the interior is alot nice and the seats are way better the yaris does have that go kart feel to it which is nice. I would never even consider the versa just plain ugly and doesnt have any sort of sport feel to it.

09-06-2010, 03:49 PM	#10
yariphilia Drives: 08 lb Join Date: Apr 2010 Location: tampa Posts: 13	lol, i actually kinda like my versa, but for me its getting 30mpg versus 42mpg in my yaris that keeps me driving it... that and my yaris is manual. the versa rides like a larger car, much smoother than my yaris was stock. as for the fit, i like them a lot. actually tried trading in my versa for one.